Negative.

I am a meat popsicle.

  • 15 Posts
  • 382 Comments
Joined 17 days ago
cake
Cake day: December 28th, 2025

help-circle

  • But it isn’t the same argument.

    When DJs sample, they choose the samples, choose the pitch and playback speed, and choose where and when to put the sample in their songs.

    There is no human intentionality in AI-created music. No one decided what the song should sound like, it’s a mash of what an algorithm calculates is the most predictable next sound based on its prompt, and it calculates what’s next by illegally using the intellectual properties of real humans.

    Whoever used this argument with you isn’t arguing in good faith.

    Edit - I didn’t even answer the overarching question. You’ll find, in almost all cases, that it isn’t the same argument because one or more things that factor into the decision will have changed. Very rarely is a situation entirely static, and if some variables have changed, then the entire argument must be reconsidered.