• 0 Posts
  • 16 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: April 21st, 2024

help-circle








  • There’s a couple thing to keep in mind that might help it make sense. Meta-analyses, though not without merit, don’t always accomplish the intended goals for a few reasons, two of which this study specifically suffers from. The first is that they combine studies that when they were conducted may have looked at the desired treatments and controls, but they often are doing so in different populations (note they stratify results by elderly, cancer patients etc.) I’m not going to on my phone start pulling the references, but I would venture to guess that the included studies have all sorts of specific groups they were targeting which leads to heterogeniety both in effect size but in interpretation of effect size. Think about it this way, if you are using Dat from many studies with different (often very specific) target populations, does it really make sense to combine them to draw conclusions about a some hypothetical population comprised of those people?

    The second thing is sample size. A few thousand seems like a lot until you realize the data in question is incidence. Each subject included either had the disease or they didn’t (it’s 0 or 1) nothing in-between and nothing outside. Interval inference for dichotomous data (especially when it gets substratified down like the authors have done here) often lead to results like the plain language summary presented. That is, everything is null because they tried to say too much, with too little data.

    Takeaway is don’t read too much into the findings. The authors were certainly trying to earnestly answer the question (probably), but the existing literature and available data came up short.






  • My tipping point with my family was George Floyd/ Breanna Taylor. The details aren’t important and are very similar to many of the stories here. Its not easy, it wasn’t then and it still has a sting to it. Good for you for deciding that enough was enough. And a pat on the back to this whole thread because I don’t think theres a single troll in it. Just folks genuinely sharing their stories of grief over a situation we’d rather not deal with. The internet like a broke clock is capable of getting it right twice a day.


  • Another thing to think about, inline with the last few comments, is that if you have 45 days worth of muscle memory you might just be doing too much too soon. 20 miles where I live in the southern US, this time of year can be taxing with the heat even if you are a career commuter. That said until your body gets used to restoring itself in between rides you’re going to drag. And when you get worn down your body wants to just diesel in a lower gear.

    Its just my two cents, but I’d recommend shorter distances, pushing a little harder over those shorter distances but in intervals. In time I bet you’ll find that you are getting there quicker with seemingly less effort.