Frivolous_Beatnik [comrade/them, any]

  • 0 Posts
  • 190 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: November 13th, 2024

help-circle















  • I think you were being overly uncharitable in assuming most of the opinion was influenced by chud talking points. My opinion is one I have formed over reading many works of fiction - I cast no judgment on people who enjoy the work, and I don’t even anticipate that the angle that I find uncomfortable was intended, I said as much many times.

    I found it too reminiscent of nearly ubiquitous tropes that, whether or not you agree the author intended it, put me off the work. It literally cannot be argued, it’s my reaction that is tainted by the prevailing currents of popular media

    I’m glad you enjoy it! I actually find the demon elements of the show a much less compelling concept than other themes it runs with. I get the angle you’re talking about, with demons (as with historical representations of vampires etc) representing the unfeeling, murderous and deceptive force that at its core has no care for life or humanity. I actually liked how the theme can be applied in other works, like Sinners, representing the faceless assimilation that will play whatever advantage it has to get its claws into the colonized people

    The rhetoric around it in Frieren just hews a little too close to actual excuses for heinous acts that it feels gross to me.

    I don’t think it necessiated a 100+ comment deep-nesting yknow?

    Also 100% some people got mad, I find it ridiculous how I and some other users were being painted with the brush of swallowing a chud narrative, being “tumblr” about it (sounding very much like a chud talking point), etc. It’s a matter of personal taste and I don’t think it’s a baseless critique at all, as fuel for discussion not condemnation





  • That’s a different argument though - they can be described as psychopathic and lacking empathy, sure, but there are humans who lack empathy, and they’re still people. The demons clearly have logical thought processes but have very different goals & priorities that are orthogonal to humans’. It all seems very “handwavy” and inconsistent to me, and if that’s the creator’s 5d chess maneuvers to create a discussion then I suppose I’m not on their level lol.

    ““The elf anime that makes the villians non sentient so you dont have to feel bad about the protagonist lighting them up with her super strong magics is actually colonalist and white supremacist” ass mf”

    I’m just weary and wary of this “fantasy race you can just kill without feeling bad about” trope

    At least pretend to read what I’m saying lol - or just go back to reddit, that’d be cool too