I am not by any means excusing Thom Yorkes or Johnny Greenwoods genocide and being a Radiohead fan in 2025 is me doubling down on separating the art from the artist. But I Just can’t find myself not listening to them, it’s impossible.

The reason I wanted to make this post is because of the recent article that came out where Thom is like “so anyway the witch-hunt keeps me up at night” over the backlash he’s received for his support of Israel… in that thread there were thousands upon thousands of commenters saying “Radiohead has always been bad” or “Radiohead is cringe.” Yeah, okay, like you aren’t their number one fan on Spotify wrapped and you weren’t anticipating to get a video message from them after being top 5% of their listeners…

This is the band that made OK Computer… the band that followed up with KID A… and you can type with a straight face “uhhh I never liked them anyway they were cringe…” I’ll take “I’m just preaching to the choir for 1200 Alex.” OK Computer is literally a commentary on everything we are existing in today, right now… just because the message was produced by NOW SHITHEADS Thom Yorke and Johnny Greenwood… does their art has to be dismissed in its entirety?

I saw another comment saying “their only good song was Karma Police and they’ll never make a hit like that again.” More lies. Radiohead makes music for THEM and the people who understand the music. I’m not trying to be the stereotypical “uhhh you just don’t know them, man…” but most people DONT know them and assume they’re the “Creep band” when in reality they are the ensemble that fine tunes their sound specifically with each record release. If they really wanted to, they could make a hit like Gangnam Style, they literally could make a song so popular it gets billions of streams around the world. Why don’t they do that? Because they have integrity and that’s rare these days when you have copy paste artists like Charlie XCX, Ellie Goulding, Taylor Swift who are copy paste and heavily manufactured by the industry replicating previous generations of music icons consisting of Whitney Houston and Lady Gaga… can you tell me then who Radiohead is trying to be other than themselves? I’ll wait. Oh, you can’t give me an answer? That’s because they are their own sound. We’re talking about the band that recorded The Bends and KID A at ABBEY FUCKING ROAD just before it got shut.

So, while their stance politically is immoral and subject to valid scrutiny, the music they make is some of the greatest we’ve ever been blessed with. To be alive the same time as OK Computer and In Rainbows is a one in a billion billion chance and that makes me a “Billionaire” in my eyes like that hack Bruno Mars made a song about, it might as well been about being a Radiohead fan

  • ghost_of_faso3@lemmygrad.ml
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    24
    ·
    edit-2
    22 days ago

    Because they have integrity and that’s rare these days when you have copy paste artists like Charlie XCX, Ellie Goulding, Taylor Swift who are copy paste and heavily manufactured by the industry replicating previous generations of music icons consisting of Whitney Houston and Lady Gaga

    I could level the same argument against radiohead, they are just copy pasting more interesting bands from the underground doing post-rock/indie in more innovative ways. Radiohead are as commercial as all the artists you just listed, they are signed and release thru major music labels, the only reason why you seem to think ‘the music they make is some of the greatest we’ve ever been blessed with’ is marketing PR you fell for by some upper class ghoul in a suit.

    I can barely stomach to even get through 2 minutes of there self indulgent white boy slop (before I found out they where nazis with a self-flagellation fetish who try to re-center a genocide on people who heckle them) before I reach for my noise records to hopefully erase the memory of some coked up zionist warbling about how much he hates women or whatever over a 2 note bassline they stole from actually talented artists.

    does their art has to be dismissed in its entirety?

    yes, although I dismissed them even when I was 14 as being shite, im now 32.

    Radiohead is basically if george orwell started a band, im not elaborating any further but real heads understand what I mean.

  • nefertum@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    15
    ·
    edit-2
    22 days ago

    I’m just generally not into “white guy band with guitar” music. I’m also not European or American so I don’t really have the memories of OK Computer you do. It came out when I was 17 years old and its just like fine I guess. It isn’t the kind of music I like. In the 90s I was all about Merengue Urbana, Bachata, Reggaeton and Hip Hop.

  • Moidialectica [he/him, comrade/them]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    9
    ·
    22 days ago

    I’m not actually super into Radiohead itself, but more of what Thom Yorke and the smile made, the music is good and it’s easy to listen to, I wouldn’t say it’s my absolute favourite (unless it’s like zero sum or thin thing)

    Their politics is absolutely dogshit and I’m distancing myself from their bands, but the music is good, I wish they weren’t all that.

  • CommunistCuddlefish [she/her]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    8
    ·
    edit-2
    21 days ago

    Comrade.

    I listen to a lot of black metal, which is notoriously rife with deeply reactionary asshats. Some of my favorite music is made by people whom I would slap with my tentacles if I met them on the street, or who I’m glad are dead! Doesn’t mean I’m materially supporting fascists, I won’t buy anything from them. Not their music, I won’t wear their merch, wouldn’t even buy it 2ndhand. Meanwhile, my friends don’t like this music and think these songs that I find so beautiful and entrancing are anything from “boring” to “unlistenably grating”.

    I love music in general. I love the music I mentioned in particular because the sounds jive very well with my brain. I have never once felt personally attacked or indignant at hearing people say these artists are shitty people or that their music is shitty. I have been disappointed in a few cases, and then I keep on listening to the free music because it still sounds great to me.

    You can do it too. You can handle people saying they do not personally enjoy music that you enjoy. I believe in you, Smile.

    P.S. You can think Radiohead’s music is some of the greatest we’ve ever been blessed with, but that really is just your opinion. I’ve never liked Radiohead’s music. I find it boring to downright unpleasant. My opinion is worth no more and no less than yours, and since musical taste is subjective there’s no way to argue it. My condolences to people who liked Radiohead’s music and are disappointed that the people who made that music are highly problematic. They’re going to have to learn to deal with that disappointment. Luckily, that’s pretty easy to do.

    P.P.S.

    Yeah, okay, like you aren’t their number one fan on Spotify wrapped and you weren’t anticipating to get a video message from them after being top 5% of their listeners

    Oddly specific.

    P.P.P.S.

    You know, not to sniff out sexism but it is interesting that you mention 3 “copy paste artists” “heavily manufactured by the industry replicating previous generations of music icon” and then name 2 other icons who were also, afaik, heavily manufactured by the industry in that the industry picks talented artists and then makes them into a sensation. And they’re all women while Radiohead is not. That’s odd. Jonas Bros are right there if we’re going to talk about generic music industry creations, or is there some newer equivlanet of them now?. Why do you feel so strongly about this and them? I don’t like their music but I’m not up in arms about these women’s careers being creations of the music industry. To me, XCX is cancelled for endorsing Holocaust Harris, Swift is cancelled on general vibes, I’ve never even heard of Goulding, Gaga is cancelled for Zionism, Whitney Houston I don’t know much about and what I do know is just sad, and I enjoy none of their music that I’ve heard so musically they’re in the same category as Radiohead for me.

  • lil_tank [any, he/him]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    7
    ·
    21 days ago

    What strikes me as bizarre in your rant is that you seem to completely sideline every person who don’t like pop-rock in general

    Hiphopheads generally don’t give a damn about Radiohead, lots of metalheads find them boring, classicheads barely know they exist, technoheads don’t care etc etc